Why Your Vanilla Agent Can't Handle Your Spicy Biz
- Ashlin Hadden
- May 8
- 4 min read
(And Why That's a Liability You Can't Afford to Ignore)
Let's be real for a second. You're out here building a pleasure-positive brand that empowers bodies, breaks stigmas, and puts orgasms and ownership back into the hands of the people. You're not selling grandma's candles. You're slinging vibrators, lubes, latex, and curated kink, and that's amazing.
So why in the name of all things slick and silicone are you still letting a vanilla insurance agent try to cover your very spicy business? This isn't a dig at your local All-American agent in khakis and a half-smile. We love that guy... for his ability to insure minivans and dental hygienists. But when it comes to the unique risks that come with your sensual, taboo-defying, delightfully NSFW (not safe for work) business model?
Honey, he's out of his league.
Let's Define "Vanilla Agent"
A vanilla agent is your run-of-the-mill insurance pro. They're well-meaning, but painfully underinformed about the sexual wellness industries. Their experience is built around insuring Main Street florists, real estate offices, and maybe the occasional hair salon and online business. Give them a dildo manufacturing business or a subscription box with lube samples, and their eyes will glaze over like a donut at Sunday mass.
Here's how to spot one:
They visibly blush when you say "anal beads."
They say, "We don't really write that kind of risk."
They offer you a quote without asking what's inside your products.
They avoid eye contact when you mention the name of your product.
They refer to your adult novelty store as a "retail shop for...um... adult items."
Cute. But dangerous.
What Goes Wrong with the Wrong Agent?
When you work with someone who doesn't get your industry, you end up with insurance that's:
Full of exclusions that could void your coverage.
Missing critical endorsements like product withdrawal, worldwide sales, or intellectual property defense.
Priced like a generic retail policy because they didn't factor in your actual risks.
Placed with a carrier that doesn't even realize what you do (until claim time).
That means one lawsuit, one regulatory audit, or one spicy slip-up and suddenly, your policy ghosts you harder than a bad Tinder date.
Real Talk: They Might Be Judging You
How do I know this? I used to be one of them. I used to focus on the moms who drive the minivans in one of the most affluent counties in Indiana. I used to solely focus on events that I KNEW those moms would be attending, and like many mainstream agents (and their underwriters), I was still operating with outdated stigmas about sexual wellness. Some carriers outright refuse to cover adult-themed businesses. Others will place your policy, but with enough exclusions to make it useless. Until now! You deserve better. Your brand is valid. Your work is empowering. And your insurance should reflect that. At Essence, we don't side-eye your Instagram. We double it, follow it, support it, and now INSURE it!
True Story Time
We once had a client who came to us after working with a traditional agent. She ran a high-end, body-safe toy brand with a huge following. Everything was going great until a customer claimed an allergic reaction to a "natural" lube in one of her kits.
She filed a claim.
Her carrier denied it.
Why? Because the policy her vanilla agent sold her had a clause that excluded bodily contact products.
Let that sink in.
She sold pleasure products and wasn't covered for bodily contact.
It's giving: malpractice. It's giving: "I don't actually read my clients' applications." It's giving: "He thought it was a candle store."
We fixed it moving forward, but we could not get her covered for a past event. it cost her money, time, and trust in the industry. Trust we are earning back every year.
Pleasure is Complex. Insurance Should Be Smart.
We know your industry because we insure it daily. We've read the FDA disclaimers. We've attended the expos. We speak lube, latex, and logistics. And we understand how nuanced your coverage needs really are.
For example:
If you're manufacturing, your product liability should address supply chain risks, recall expenses, and international sales exposure.
If you're private labeling, you're still on the hook if something goes wrong. We make sure you're protected.
If you're retailing, we look at storefront risks, shoplifting, slip-and-fall, and cyber coverage.
If you're selling online, we factor in data protection, shipping liability, and intellectual property exposure.
If you're educating, coaching, or content creating, you need professional liability for the advice you're giving.
See? Not so cookie-cutter now, is it?
What Makes Essence Different?
We're not your mom's insurance agency - unless your mom sells BDSM furniture and hosts Yoni mapping workshops (in which case... hi, we'd love to insure her too).
At Essence, we:
Specialize in the adult and sexual wellness space.
Advocate for your brand, not against it.
Work with carriers who won't flinch at your product line.
Translate "insurance speak" into sass and safety.
Deliver policies that actually work when things hit the fan (or the lube hits the floor).
Red Flags Your Agent Can't Handle Your Biz
Still not sure if your current agent is up to the task? Look for these spicy red flags:
They've never been to a sexual wellness conference or vendor show.
They can't explain claims-made vs. occurrence coverage.
They ask if your site is "safe for work" before quoting.
They recommend general liability only and call it a day.
They didn't ask about ingredients, packaging, or international reach.
If any of this sounds familiar, it's time for an upgrade.
Bottom Line (Pun Fully Intended)
Your business isn't basic. Your coverage shouldn't be either.
Don't settle for agents who think you're "too edgy" or who offer one-size-fits-all policies. You deserve protection that's as bold, intentional, and innovative as the brand you're building.
And frankly? It's sexy to be secure.
So let your vanilla agent get back to insuring candle stores.
We'll be over here insuring your empire, one vibrator, whip, and bottle of lube at a time.
Ready to Ditch the Vanilla?
Call or email us today for a free coverage consultation.
765-432-8989
You bring the spice.
We'll bring the coverage that doesn't flinch.
Comments